News Messageboard

News message board

Sify Home >> News >> Messageboard

Message Board

Select a topic

Is Vande Mataram unIslamic

The Jamiat-e-Ulema Hind (JEU) has asked Muslims to refrain from singing Vande Matram song as some portions of it are anti-Islam. What is your take on this?

More>>

	*
	*
	*
Maximum characters allowed - 1000



Fields marked with * are Mandatory

Latest Messages

Total messages : 323 | Today’s messages : 0

Posted By: miraj

On:10/11/2009

Delhi bandh by BJP.

ALL BS by Gyypsies to control the bjp-congress nexxus and keep it alive.

same sorts of guuys raised bofors from bjp so as to control it and save congress.

Both angrez created congress and their nexxus partner bjp need to end.

Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward

Posted By: faheem iqbal

On:08/11/2009

sare jahan se hindustan hamara but really vande matram unislamic

Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward

Posted By: faheem iqbal

On:08/11/2009

sare jahan se hindustan hamara but really vande matram really unislamic

Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward

Posted By: faheem iqbal

On:08/11/2009

sare jahan se hindustan hamara but really vande matram really unislamic

Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward

Posted By: s g mali

On:05/11/2009

Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward

Posted By: Hindusthani

On:05/11/2009

Vande Mataram is our National Song, MUST be RESPECTED by everybody!
Nowadays some Fanatic Muslims put their heads infront of idiots like JEU's.
True muslims understands the difference between respect and Bow.
Don't we respect our mother? Has Islam taught Muslims not to respect their mothers?
Nation comes before the Religion.
India is the only country where we tolerate all this non-sence by the name of a Religion.
Fxxx all these so called Leaders misused by the dirty politicians to divide and rule us.
Send all Fanatic JEUs to the Hell so that Good Muslims can peacefully stay in India as an Indian.
JEU followers, Stay in India like a True Indian or simply 'Quit India'

Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward

Posted By: PP

On:05/11/2009

Absolutely NO
Niether it is a Hindu song nor Islamic .Totally rubbish

Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward

Posted By: Hindusthani

On:05/11/2009

Don't we respect our mother? Has Islam taught Muslims not to respect their mothers?
Nation comes before the Religion.
India is the only country where we tolerate all this non-sence by the name of a Religion.
Fxxx all these so called Leaders misused by the dirty politicians to divide and rule us.
Send all Fanatic JEUs to the Hell so that Good Muslims can peacefully stay in India as an Indian.
JEU followers, Stay in India like a True Indian or simply 'Quit India'

Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward

Posted By: Enter your Namesheik.k.v

On:05/11/2009

it is not,unnecessary it is being giving un due importance to disrupt communal harmony in our mother land.

Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward

Posted By: Vande Mataram

On:05/11/2009

Yes, it may be un-Islamic. It is not rocket science either to surmise that a majority Hindu country may have something objectionable to other religions by way of custom or practice. The most important thing however is tolerance of another’s belief systems and customs so long as they do not deny the fundamental freedom espoused in the constitution of the country. One does not have to recite the national song to prove his/her allegiance to the country and its constitution. By the same token one does not have to proclaim every now and then that his belief systems are at odd with that of the majority. Insistence on either will only cause conflicts. Tolerance is to acknowledge differences if not celebrate them in a spirit of accommodation. One needs to take a strong stance however, when such differences create social chaos. Political parties are trying their best to engineer that citing every difference. Glad to note that people in general are not buying in. God bless everyone.

Post Reply | View Reply(1)| Report abuse | Forward

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next >>

Sify Specials

News Quiz

Live News

Brahmotsavam Live streaming

Most Read

Sangh parivar activists involved in Kandhamal riot: Naveen Patnaik

India can't be a 'carbon copy' of China: PM

Advani wants Liberhan report tabled in parliament

No war in Mumbai police, says Commissioner Sivanandan

Get lost, Liberhan tells media

More News


	Opinion Poll Is Rahul Bhatt, son of film maker Mahesh Bhatt, innocent? Yes No Can`t say