About Us | Feedback | Advertise
Discussions
Sify Home >> Connect >> Discussions >> Government >> Indo-Pak Issues >> Other
Discussions   Other  Need Help?
Topic : Reservation should be based only on economic criteria.
Replied to :
Total number of Replies for Topic : 331 Create : NewTopic   
Posted by :     stalemate ( 18:02:2005 09:02 )     | Post a reply to this message Tree view  |  Message No. : 24498  
Reservation should be based only on economic criteria.
In a country like India, where economic disparity is really huge, economic criteria should be the only consideration for policies on reservation.
Message Rating: Rate this message Send Private Message to stalemate | Track User | Add topic to my favourite |Add This thread to my favourite

3 Replies 
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3
Posted by :   hariprasath_02 ( 20:05:2008 17:54 )
  I disagree with this.

No, I disagree with this concept.  In a democratic country like India, reservation should be granted.  Only 40% of the seats were granted for reservation.  Those who agree with the above topic can express their talents to gain 60% of the other seats.  It is due to the reservation their be distribution of several other communities(including backward, SC,& ST) in a particular organization.  If reservation does not persists, then there will be accumulation of only one or two kind of castes.  For this problem it is better to remove all castes from the indian jurisdiction.  Then we can solve this problem in mere future.
Rate this message Send Private Message to hariprasath_02 | Track user | Add topic to my favourite |Add this thread to my favourite |Post a reply to this message
Posted by :   ammanni ( 15:07:2007 21:00 )
  Caste based reservation.

The reservation was meant for one generation i.e. 15 years at the time of independence and was conceded as a compromise to get Mr. Ambedkar's support for independence. Rest what followed is the vote bank politics of the political parties. If the present trend is any guide it is futile to hope for any logical actions from any government as all of them are trapped in their own web of vote banks.
Rate this message Send Private Message to ammanni | Track user | Add topic to my favourite |Add this thread to my favourite |Post a reply to this message
Posted by :   ssmani46 ( 22:09:2006 15:46 )
  What for reservation first?

I agree.

First of all all politicians shout from tree tops that caste must be abolished. They also claim reservations are the only way to uplift the downtroden.

What is meant by uplifting? Increasing the income level only! After 50  years of reservation some people have been benefitted. And some have had negative effects.

Hence if the ill effects of castism must be eliminated and at the same time the lower level people must become prosperous, the only way is to apply reservation based on income only and not based on caste.

Educated, well to do people from such reservation hungry catses must themselves lead from the front if they have are self respecting people.

Today in the so called forward communities of Tamilnadu atleast, dowry has become insignificant: This change came about only from within! This example can be definitely emulated by others in all applicable fields.
Rate this message Send Private Message to ssmani46 | Track user | Add topic to my favourite |Add this thread to my favourite |Post a reply to this message


My Forums Edit My Profile Preferences Advanced Search NRI Archives
Private Message User Rating Msg Rating Track User Add Topic to my Favourite Add Thread to my Favourite
Report a violator
 
  Search for      by      in      
© Copyright Sify Ltd, 1998-2006. All rights reserved. India News Portal, Sify.com hosted at SifyHosting India's first Level 3 Internet Data Centre.
Site optimized for Internet Explorer 5.5 and above.
See Disclaimer | Privacy Policy & Parental Guidance on pornography | Careers@sify | About Us | Feedback | Advertise with us | Site Map